Rate Your Judge Colorado

Judges · Prosecutors

Rate a Colorado judge or prosecutor in 30 seconds. Anonymous. Everyone sees the result.

Rate Your JudgeCOLORADO

Judge Carl S. McGuire III

Judge · 13th Judicial District, Colorado · 1650 Donelan Avenue Suite 104, Burlington, CO 80807

13th Judicial District. No ratings yet. Be the first to rate Judge Carl S. McGuire III: anonymous, 30 seconds, from your phone.

State evaluation (Colorado Commission on Judicial Performance): 2024: meets performance standards (vote 6-0); 2018: meets performance standards. On the bench since 2016.

State survey for the 2024 evaluation (run by Market Decisions Research): 11 of 216 attorneys invited by email answered; 3 of 106 non-attorneys invited by email answered; the judicial district has 79,465 residents (2020 Census). State survey report.

Colorado Court of Appeals decisions on this judge’s rulings announced since June 2023: 11 (7 affirmed, 2 affirmed in part, reversed in part, 2 reversed).

Rate Judge Carl S. McGuire III · How it works · Our method