Rate Your Judge Colorado

Judges · Prosecutors

Rate a Colorado judge or prosecutor in 30 seconds. Anonymous. Everyone sees the result.

Rate Your JudgeCOLORADO

Judge Jay Edwards

Judge · Rio Blanco County, Colorado · 209 E. Main Street, Rangely, CO 81648

Rio Blanco County. No ratings yet. Be the first to rate Judge Jay Edwards: anonymous, 30 seconds, from your phone.

Judge Edwards received his bachelor's degree from Mesa State College in Grand Junction (now Colorado Mesa University) and his law degree from the University of Arkansas School of Law. He practiced law in Rogers, Arkansas. From 2018 until his appointment he served as the Meeker Town Judge.

He was appointed to the County Court in 2023.

State evaluation (Colorado Commission on Judicial Performance): 2026: meets performance standards. On the bench since 2023.

State survey for the 2026 evaluation (run by Market Decisions Research): 2 of 76 attorneys invited by email answered; 5 of 232 non-attorneys invited by email answered; the judicial district has 85,572 residents (2020 Census). State survey report.

We searched the Colorado Court of Appeals’ weekly announcements from June 1, 2023 to October 22, 2026 and found no decisions on this judge’s rulings. This is not a grade: only appealed rulings appear in those announcements, and a judge with few appealable rulings, or one appointed recently, will often have none.

Rate Judge Jay Edwards · How it works · Our method